- Elizabeth Larson
Supervisors reappoint planning commissioners; recruitment still under way for District 3 seat
LAKEPORT, Calif. – Last Tuesday, as part of its first meeting of the year, the Board of Supervisors established its leadership for the coming year, and made a number of committee and commission appointments, including determining the members of the Lake County Planning Commission.
The board elected Anthony Farrington the chair for 2015, with Rob Brown elected vice chair.
In the case of the Lake County Planning Commission – a general advisory body to the board on land use issues – that body also has five seats, one for each supervisorial district.
As such, each supervisor appoints their representative on the commission for a term of two years.
Four of the five members will be returning for another term.
District 1 Supervisor Jim Comstock reappointed Joe Sullivan, District 2 Supervisor Jeff Smith reappointed Bob Malley, District 4 Supervisor Anthony Farrington reappointed Don Deuchar and District 5 Supervisor Rob Brown reappointed Gil Schoux.
When the turn came for new District 3 Supervisor Jim Steele to make his appointment, he made a motion to have his wife, Olga Martin Steele – who was outgoing District 3 Supervisor Denise Rushing’s planning commissioner – put on the commission in an interim capacity.
He said he was interviewing some commission candidates and would back in “at least a month” with a permanent nominee, noting, “I haven’t had time to advertise this fully.”
His fellow board members were unanimous in opposing Steele’s proposal, voicing their concerns that the interim appointment would create not just a perception of a conflict of interest, but lead to an actual conflict situation.
Brown said perception of conflict is an issue every supervisor has to deal with, but in this case he felt the issue went beyond perception to a “clear conflict.”
He suggested that the position be kept vacant for the short-term. Brown said there is precedent, as in past cases when a commissioner has died and the seat is left open while a replacement is chosen.
Comstock agreed that keeping the District 3 commission seat vacant temporarily would be better than having a conflict.
“The relationship that each of us supervisors have with our planning commissioner is different,” Brown added. “It depends on the board member. But in the 14 years that I’ve been on the board, I have never once had a discussion with my planning commissioner, because it has to be independent of the board,” and keeping that distance would be difficult with a spouse.
“I can take advice from the board members, and I certainly accept their view on this and so I’ll withdraw that recommendation,” Steele said. “It will have to remain vacant for a month.”
Replied Comstock, “It doesn’t even have to be a month,” but can be sooner, based on when Steele has a final candidate.
Steele said people were reporting to him that they hadn’t heard about the opening, which he said he had publicized in the newspaper.
Farrington told Steele that keeping the position vacant for now was “a good decision.”
Like Brown, he noted that each of the supervisors has a different relationship with their planning commissioners.
“I haven’t even seen my planning commissioner in a year,” said Farrington. “There’s an insulation there that I think is a value and to the public trust, and so I think it’s hard to overcome that when it’s your wife. And so I know you’re just trying to fill the gap until you select somebody, and that’s noble, but I do believe it creates a perception problem, not just for yourself, but for the entire county.”
Steele said his wife likely would be relieved at not having to fulfill the commitment.
Anyone interested in applying for the District 3 planning commission position can contact the Board of Supervisors’ office at 707-263-2368 or download the advisory board application at http://www.co.lake.ca.us/Government/Boards/Board_of_Supervisors.htm .
Email Elizabeth Larson at