- Elizabeth Larson
Demolition of damaged homes at Lakeside Heights begins
LAKEPORT, Calif. – On Monday afternoon, Scott Spivey looked on as an excavator tore through the walls of the Tudor-style home he and wife Robin had shared in the Lakeside Heights subdivision.
The home, located on Lancaster Road, was perched on a hillside over Hill Road with a view of Clear Lake. Built in 1985, it had been the couple's home for 11 years when cracks in the structure began to appear last spring.
The home eventually would be split in half and fall into a hole that resulted from a landslide, the cause of which is still a source of debate between subdivision residents and county officials.
The Spiveys had to leave after the county red-tagged the home on the weekend of March 23, forcing them to move out within 48 hours.
Eventually, seven structures would be red-tagged and other residents would leave based on voluntary evacuation notices the county issued, with about half of the residents in the 29-home subdivision moving out.
Late this summer, the county Community Development Department moved forward with abatements of the most severely damaged homes, including the Spivey home.
At the Sept. 17 Board of Supervisors meeting, Community Development Department Director Rick Coel told the board that he was pursuing the abatement of two structures – the Spivey home and a nearby duplex.
Having the structures out of the way, Coel said, would make recontouring the soil – part of the process to winterize the landslide area – an easier task.
On Monday, Coleman Construction – which received the county contract for demolishing the two structures – got to work taking the homes down.
Company owner Tracy Coleman said he had until Oct. 15 to remove the structures, do the soil contouring and cover the slide area above Hill Road with plastic.
The county's goal is to keep the landslide area dry and prevent the ground movement from starting again.
Randall Fitzgerald, the president of the subdivision's homeowners association, said the county sent him an abatement notice last week for the association's property above Hill Road.
The notice gave the association 48 hours to mitigate the slide area, and Fitzgerald said they let the deadline lapse, which means the county now will move forward with the abatement.
Fitzgerald told the supervisors at their Sept. 17 meeting that the association had limited funds and was doing what it could to deal with the slide.
However, he pointed out, “Every single homeowner feels that we are not responsible for the damage that has been inflicted on our neighborhood.”
It's unclear who ultimately will pay for the abatements. When the county takes over an abatement process, the property owner usually is billed.
However, the property owners maintain that the county's water system was responsible for causing the landslide, and that's what they alleged in 45 tort claims filed against the county in July.
The county's third party liability administrator denied those claims, which opens the door for the property owners to file a lawsuit within a six-month window.
Michael Green, an attorney with the Santa Rosa law firm Abbey, Weitzenberg, Warren & Emery, represents the property owners.
He told Lake County News that the property owners intend to file a single lawsuit against the county in order to recoup their losses – from destruction of homes to lost property value.
Email Elizabeth Larson at