Local Government

SOUTH LAKE COUNTY – The conclusion to the closely contested District 1 supervisorial race is less than a week away, and for those who haven't made up their minds, here's another opportunity to hear from the candidates themselves.


James Comstock and Susanne La Faver are running to succeed Supervisor Ed Robey on the Lake County Board of Supervisors. Robey is retiring at the end of his third term, which expires in December.


La Faver bested Comstock by 11 votes in the June primary, and the two have raised tens of thousands of dollars in pursuit of the south county supervisorial seat. Comstock has led the race in overall fundraising and expenditures.


Lake County News is presenting unabridged questionnaires which the candidates filled out and returned.


The topics covered in the questionnaire include development, rent stability, growth and the projects they would tackle first.


Find their questionnaires here:


District 1 supervisor candidates' questionnaires: James Comstock

District 1 supervisor candidates' questionnaires: Susanne La Faver


E-mail Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..


{mos_sb_discuss:3}

Image
James Comstock is running for the District 1 supervisorial seat. Courtesy photo.




1. Please give a basic picture of what you believe a supervisor's goals and responsibilities should be. What traits do you possess that you believe make you the best qualified to be District 1's next supervisor? What is the biggest difference between you and your opponent?{sidebar id=68}


As District 1 supervisor, I will be an advocate for and a protector of the interests of my constituents. I will work to preserve our quality of life, and to plan for the future. My 18 years experience in public service, and my deep understanding of our community, its residents and its history put me in a unique position to serve our district in ways that have been lacking for many years. I am not afraid to stand up and demand that our residents and communities receive the services and support that we have been denied, despite our contribution to the county tax base. My opponent is a comparatively new resident to the county, with no experience as an elected official. I offer deep roots and a lifelong commitment to the area, along with a proven track record of 18 years of public service.


2. Development is a main topic of discussion in this year's District 1 race. How should growth be directed in the south county in order to prevent sprawl? Do you agree more with the newly adopted General Plan or with the proposals from the Middletown Area Plan when it comes to community boundaries? Are there any proposed developments about which you're particularly concerned?


Nineteen years ago a 20-year growth plan was put into place. This plan has served us well, preserving our quality of life while managing growth. I believe that the Middletown Area Plan appropriately addresses growth for the next 20 years. Attempting to manage growth by exceptions to the general plan will result in the sprawl already demonstrated by this imprudent practice in Salem, Oregon; Idaho Falls, Idaho; and in cities across the country. We are uniquely positioned to avoid making the mistakes of history by adopting a plan for the future now, rather than waiting for developers with more money and more lawyers to push through exceptions that do not fit our community and lifestyle.


3. Supervisors must use both their own judgment and input from their constituents to make informed decisions. Explain how you would approach making a difficult decision about a divisive issue. If your personal opinion differed with those of the majority in your district, how would you reconcile those two viewpoints to make the best decision for District 1?


In my 18 years experience on the school board I have faced this situation many times. In these instances I have based my decision on facts in evidence, making the best decision for the circumstances and for my constituents. As supervisor, if my personal opinion differed from those in the majority in my district, I would, as I have in the past, make a decision based on the fact in evidence.


4. Business development and job creation are critical to our local economy. Do you have a plan for attracting new businesses to the south county and, if so, what kinds of businesses would you target? Would those include "big box" stores such as Costco, Lowe's or Home Depot? At the same time, how would you protect existing businesses?


As a supervisor, I will work to attract new business and industry to the county. By providing incentives, including zoning for a local business park with appropriate infrastructure, (i.e., water, sewer, and roads) we can attract businesses that will bring viable jobs, along with additional goods and services to the area. We need to effect a paradigm shift that changes county agencies from obstacles which must be dealt with to customer service based entities which protect the counties priorities and interests while providing appropriate service and assistance to the businesses and developers who work with them.


The newly adopted General Plan Policy LU4.6 addresses "big box" stores in unincorporated areas of the county. Small businesses provide important services to our community, and they succeed when they provide exemplary service, something that I strongly support. I support actions which allow local businesses to compete with prices offered outside of the county, and I strongly support the idea that superior customer service is what should set local businesses apart from their out of area competitors.


5. The Board of Supervisors recently adopted a resolution encouraging voluntary rent stability agreements at local mobile home parks. What is your stance on rent stability or rent control?


I am not an advocate of rent control for several reasons. I believe that government fixed rent prices do not account for natural increases in maintenance costs. Fixed rents do not allow owners to properly maintain their property, which ultimately causes blight. Having said that, I am pleased that the Board of Supervisors took a voluntary approach addressing the issue in resolution 2008-173 which allows responsible owners to adapt to their individual circumstances.


6. The Lake County Board of Supervisors is responsible for managing a budget for more than $200 million. Please explain any hands-on experience you have with managing large budgets, including situations in which you were required to make cuts and/or approve increases in spending. What would you do to make sure that the south county's needs are addressed in the county budget?


I have 18 years of hands-on experience managing of budget of over $13 million dollars as an elected school board member. I am well versed in the challenges and opportunities that come with the economic cycles of prosperous and lean times. I have a track record of managing a public budget in a way that places the needs and priorities of the public first. As I have stated before, I feel that despite the large contribution to the county tax base, the south county has been long neglected – while services were allocated disproportionately in other areas of the county, due to a lack of leadership and representation in Lakeport. I will be a strong voice and advocate for south county residents to ensure that we receive the services and attention that our tax dollars pay for.


7. With the state experiencing critically dry water years and a growing population, water is becoming an increasingly critical issue in California and here in Lake County. Do you have any ideas about how to protect local water resources in order to ensure Lake County will have enough water in the future? What meaningful part can the Board of Supervisors play in ensuring the county's water supply?


Dry years in our area are nothing new. The drought cycle in the Mediterranean climate of California's coastal range is a well-documented phenomenon which will continue. What is new is the amount of people taking water from our limited aquifer. Although I am aware that it will be a formidable task, as Supervisor I will work diligently to recover the water rights which were lost to Yolo County in 1912 by members of the Board of Supervisor lacking knowledge of the long-term ramifications. Managing appropriate growth within adequately established community boundaries will ensure that we make wise use of our natural resources. I am also in favor of working with land owners to create water retention projects which will retain riparian runoff during the wet months of the year to supplement the aquifer through our historically dry summers. The Board of Supervisors can play a meaningful part in planning for our future by supporting these projects and in stepping up to recover Lake County rights to Lake County water.


8. While supervisors specifically represent a particular area, they also have a say in matters pertaining to the rest of the county. What is the one prevailing issue facing Lake County that you're most concerned about, and what actions would you take in response to it?


I believe that as a Supervisor you first and foremost represent the residents of your district, always bearing in mind that your actions effect all 66,000 county residents. Lake County's 9.8-percent unemployment rate is the most critical issue for the Board of Supervisors, and for county residents. These figures reflect what I have been saying throughout my campaign. I will take action to bring to the county jobs that pay a living wage and provide sustainable long term employment for residents.


9. If elected, what is the first issue or project you would tackle?


From the first day of my campaign bringing jobs to District 1 has been my top priority. Lake County currently suffers from an unemployment rate of 9.8 percent. What that means is that over 6,000 residents in our communities are unable to support themselves. Even more struggle to make ends meet working hard in service industry positions that do not pay a living wage. The highest priority issue for me, and for the entire Board of Supervisors needs to be lowering the unemployment rate by attracting businesses which provide residents with living wage jobs.


10. What is your vision of Lake County in 20 years?


I have seen many changes come to Lake County over the past 58 years. In 20 years I hope to see Lake County successfully supporting residents living in a fabulous rural environment. Forty-seven percent of county land is publicly owned. These beautiful open spaces will not change, but will remain in perpetuity as a heritage for the coming generations. I want to create an environment where multiple generations are able to live, work, and recreate in our beautiful county, and I am committed to creating a job base that is sufficient to support that.


{mos_sb_discuss:3}

CLEARLAKE – It's been a busy season for local races, with a packed field of candidates seeking office on the Clearlake City Council.


This year's candidates are Estella Creel, Curt Giambruno, Joyce Overton, James Reed, Bill Shields and Judy Thein.


This week Lake County News is presenting unabridged questionnaires which the candidates filled out and returned. Candidate Estella Creel chose not to participate.


Today features responses by Giambruno, the current mayor, along with the ideas and proposals from challengers Reed and Shields. Shields did not respond the questionnaire but instead submitted campaign literature which has been reproduced.


Find Giambruno's, Reed's and Shield's statements here:


Clearlake Council candidates' questionnaires: Curt Giambruno

Clearlake Council candidates' questionnaires: James Reed

Clearlake Council candidates' questionnaires: Bill Shields


On Tuesday, Lake County News published questionnaires from Overton and Thein. Find their questionnaires here:


Clearlake Council candidates' questionnaires: Joyce Overton

Clearlake Council candidates' questionnaires: Judy Thein


E-mail Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..


{mos_sb_discuss:3}

Image
James Reed is seeking a seat on the Clearlake City Council this year. Courtesy photo.
 

 


James M. Reed


Age: 49


Experience in government and community service: Little League umpire/assistant football coach.



1. Explain what you believe a city council member's responsibilities are. How would you fulfill these? What qualifications do you possess that make you a good candidate for office?


A) One of the council's main duties is the enactment of the city's annual budget. Council sets fiscal policies and approves all spending, whether for operations (e.g., salaries) or capital items such as major equipment purchases, street repairs or other public improvements. Council members will often propose new programs at the suggestion of city residents.


Council members also respond annually to thousands of constituent requests, filling a crucial oversight role in the delivery of basic city services to the public.


(Taken from council duties of Rochester, NY.)


B) My goal is to sit down with our city's administrator and be able to prioritize the various needs that is a major concern to our constituency.


C) My ability to articulate and to speak concisely to the needs of my community. With my managerial skills, I believe I would be able to negotiate deals which could make our city more prosperous.


2. Explain how your management style would be applied to your position as council member. Are you hands-on or do you set policy and delegate?


My managerial style allows me to look at each situation separately and judge accordingly.


3. Large developments are proposed for Clearlake and surrounding areas, particularly the Provinsalia development near Cache Creek, the Serenity Cove project on the lakeshore and increased commercial development along Highway 53. What is your opinion on these various projects? Are they good for Clearlake? Why or why not? Are there any other developments that you think are either good or bad for the city?


With our present economy in the current disarray, I feel that both projects would help us immensely in obtaining certain growth. But through my research, I have discovered that one of the projects may be on hold for at least the next two and a half years depending upon the financial turnaround of our economic status both here and nationally. Right now, I believe projects, such as "big box stores," would have an immediate impact that could bring in quick revenue to help establish revitalization of our city.


4. For several years the Clearlake Police Department's budget has been augmented by the Measure P sales tax approved by voters. Do you support continuing to augment the police department budget? Are there different approaches that you, as a council member, would take when addressing the police department?


If it's a way to improve our city's infrastructure ...Yes!


5. The city's redevelopment plan has two years remaining in its implementation. Updating the plan is being proposed to extend it for another 10 years. Do you support extending redevelopment in Clearlake? Why or why not?


I support Larry the cable guy ... "GIT ER DUN.” I believe that if there has been a plan that was implemented and has been approved, why prolong something that would grow our community, increase integrity and boost morale?


6. In September of 2007, the Clearlake Vision Task Force presented to the council a 60-page report that lays out a vision for the city, from improved infrastructure and public facilities to ways to build the economic base and create a sustainable city. What is your opinion on the value of the report? Do you think its ideas can be achieved? What would you as a council member do to carry the vision forward?


I found the report to be very informative with a lot of foresight. It seems that the task force's vision correlates with what I had in mind for redevelopment with special emphasis placed upon having a scenic drive down Lakeshore Boulevard.


Look for funds in order to make the redevelopment of this project happen.


7. Some issues that come before the council can be extremely divisive, both among council members and city residents. How would you address clashing opinions when approaching a decision? What experience do you have in working with others when there are no easy answers but a decision has to be made?


A) I would cast my vote accordingly for the betterment of the community rather than for myself or others as politicians; I work for the people.

B) There are never easy answers ... there is always a decision to be made. I make my decisions according to the situation.


8. If elected, is there any project or issue you plan to tackle first?


Street improvements (sidewalks and new streets).


9. Public safety is an important issue in Clearlake. How would you as a council member seek to improve safety and reduce crime in the city's neighborhoods?


It seems that most crimes here are of a domestic nature. Having said that, I would seek to increase awareness and support to individuals that are involved in battered situations.


10. When you think of Clearlake's future, what do you want the city to look like in 10, 20 and 30 years?


I would like to have the appearance of prosperity; to have the morale of the people uplifted and our surroundings the become beautified by way of city and community efforts. Ten, 20 or 30 years has to begin with now.


{mos_sb_discuss:3}

CLEARLAKE – As the Nov. 4 election gets closer, voters have a big field of candidates to choose from when it comes to filling three open seats on the Clearlake City Council.


Estella Creel, Curt Giambruno, Joyce Overton, James Reed, Bill Shields and Judy Thein are seeking the seats in this year's election, as Lake County News has reported.


This week Lake County News is presenting unabridged questionnaires which the candidates filled out and returned. Candidate Estella Creel chose not to participate.


The first installment begins with Joyce Overton and Judy Thein. Both women are incumbents seeking reelection at the end of their first terms on the council.


In their questionnaires Overton and Thein lay out their ideas of leadership, council responsibility and the future of the city.


Find their questionnaires here:


Clearlake Council candidates' questionnaires: Joyce Overton

Clearlake Council candidates' questionnaires: Judy Thein


E-mail Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..


{mos_sb_discuss:3}

Image
Joyce Overton is seeking reelection to the Clearlake City Council this November. Courtesy photo.

 

 

Joyce Overton


Age: 51


Family: Six daughters, two sons, four granddaughters, five grandsons – this includes my children, stepchildren and foster children.


Experience in government and community service: I have sat on the Clearlake City Council for the past four years. I am a state board member on the California League of Cities and the vice president for the Redwood Empire Division of the California League of Cities.


Endorsements: Congressman Mike Thompson, state Sen. Pat Wiggins, Assembly member Patty Berg, Supervisors Denise Rushing and Ed Robey, and many from our community.



1. Explain what you believe a city council member's responsibilities are. How would you fulfill these? What qualifications do you possess that make you a good candidate for office?


The main responsibility of the City Council is to create and enforce policies and procedures but it goes much farther than that. We are public servants, mediators, counselors, human resource and problem solvers.


I would fulfill this by working together with other council members and staff to fulfill the needs of the community. Listen to the community about what they feel is needed and why, and take that into consideration when making my decisions.


My experience in corporate and small business management over the past 25 years has given me the experience to take these positions. Along with past experience I continue to take training classes on how to work with my fellow council members, staff and public. Over the past four years I have continued to volunteer in our community and sit on committees that will help our community.


2. Explain how your management style would be applied to your position as council member. Are you hands-on or do you set policy and delegate?


My management style is hands-on, policy and delegate setting. In order to be a good leader you must be involved by doing, but must also be able to delegate and set the rules. You should not expect anyone do to something you would not do yourself but must no where do draw the line on who is in charge. You can never let your personal feeling get in the way of doing your job. It should make no difference whether you like someone or not on how you handle city business.


3. Large developments are proposed for Clearlake and surrounding areas, particularly the Provinsalia development near Cache Creek, the Serenity Cove project on the lakeshore and increased commercial development along Highway 53. What is your opinion on these various projects? Are they good for Clearlake? Why or why not? Are there any other developments that you think are either good or bad for the city?


We all want to keep Clearlake as rural as possible but reality is more people are staying here and making this their home. We must create not only jobs but jobs that pay a living wage. At this point most of our revenue goes over the mountain and not only is costing the city money but costs our citizens money because they have to go out of town to shop. With gas prices skyrocketing we need to find a way to keep the money at home. Shop local is one of the most important things to do to keep a city frugal. Development is good as long as the developers listen to the people and so far these developers have tried to do everything the people and staff has asked for. Shopping is great but we need to find something else besides fast food and stores for jobs. This is a hard find because of the access to Lake County and at this time our economic status makes it a hard for anyone to start up a business. We need to find something that fits and will protect or air and water ways.


4. For several years the Clearlake Police Department's budget has been augmented by the Measure P sales tax approved by voters. Do you support continuing to augment the police department budget? Are there different approaches that you, as a council member, would take when addressing the police department?


Measure P has been an issue from the beginning. One reason is because the people voted on something they did not have all the information on. Sixty-three percent of our general fund goes to our police department, leaving only 37 percent for us to run the city. We will always have a police department but I feel there is a better way to handle the money that comes into the city. With the way Measure P is set up, it leaves us very little flexibility. I am hoping that in the near future we can work on this measure and find a way to make it work better for the community.


5. The city's redevelopment plan has two years remaining in its implementation. Updating the plan is being proposed to extend it for another 10 years. Do you support extending redevelopment in Clearlake? Why or why not?


I do support extending our redevelopment plan. It is unfortunate that the redevelopment was not used correctly. This is where having the right administrator, staff and training come in. I believe that if the council had been trained on redevelopment they would have known that the money was not being used and could have done some projects that would have beautified Clearlake and created new businesses, and in return would have increased tourism to Clearlake. It all comes down to the council members need for educated.


6. In September of 2007, the Clearlake Vision Task Force presented to the council a 60-page report that lays out a vision for the city, from improved infrastructure and public facilities to ways to build the economic base and create a sustainable city. What is your opinion on the value of the report? Do you think its ideas can be achieved? What would you as a council member do to carry the vision forward?


Visions are great but with out a plan it goes no where. We have had a lakeshore plan before and nothing happened. We need an implementation plan. When things like visions or plans are put together we need to also include how this can take place. How is this going to happen?


It always takes community involvement to implement the plan. Without everyone on board it will not take place and we will stay the same as we are now. I know everyone wants to clean up and make this town a place we can be proud of but it always seems to be talk and no action. We have an economic development committee that is open to the public. This committee is supposed to set a plan for implementation but when no one comes, it is hard to do that. The community needs to get involved. Remember you are the city, not me or the committee members but you the citizens of Clearlake. I would like to see the community get involved more and as a council member I will work harder to see this happen. Four years ago I said I wanted more involvement from the community and we now have two community committees. It’s a start. With the budget cuts we are lucky to have them. My hope is that the citizens of Clearlake start getting involved with their community. The council can not do it alone.


7. Some issues that come before the council can be extremely divisive, both among council members and city residents. How would you address clashing opinions when approaching a decision? What experience do you have in working with others when there are no easy answers but a decision has to be made?


This is where training comes in. As a council member there has been a few times after a council meeting I wished I had handled things differently. I had the opportunity to go to training and I took that chance. Of course, one time is not enough but it did give me some tools to handle different situations. I am trying to put it to work; changing the way you do things takes concentration and practice and I plan on working on myself to make this happen. It is not an easy task when opinions clash. If you have 100 people you most likely will have 100 different ways to get something accomplished. You must find a common ground. Everyone wanting the best for the city is how this gets accomplished. All roads lead to the same place it is just which one to take. This is where my experience in management comes in. You cannot let your personal feelings come into play. That is hard and I myself have let this happen, but it never is good.


You must keep an open mind because as a city council member it is not my opinion that matters but yours. Never make a final decision till you have heard from everyone and have been given all the facts then make the best decision for the majority of the people.


8. If elected, is there any project or issue you plan to tackle first?


My first project is working with the community and the churches to find a way to help the least privileged. With the economic system falling we will have more families and individuals that need shelter and my hope is to help fill that need.


My second project is the Department of Motor Vehicles office. I have been working on this with Patty Berg’s office this year but with the state budget, it has been difficult at best to work with DMV. My object here is to have our DMV office open at least two days a week and more than six hours a day. We will have surveys out there in the near future and I hope the county residents that would use this office participate in that survey.


9. Public safety is an important issue in Clearlake. How would you as a council member seek to improve safety and reduce crime in the city's neighborhoods?


Public safety is a council member’s No. 1 priority. We have this past year, with new road construction had the curb cuts put in, enlarge the cross walk and large strips at Austin Park crossing for safety. I would like, in the near future, when finance allows, having fluorescent signs by the walk ways to slow down the vehicles around pedestrian cross walks. This is an inexpensive way to help protect the pedestrians when crossing fast moving traffic areas.


Crime is a big concern for our neighborhoods. Gang prevention and the community creating neighborhood watch programs is a step in the right direction. The problem is that people are afraid to step up because they fear recourse from either the gang or sometimes the police. This is what I heard from the people. We must change this. We cannot be afraid or the gang will take over our city. You can not run gangs out if you are afraid, that is what they are counting on. Sometimes you have to put your life on the line for the welfare of the people and I am willing to do that.


10. When you think of Clearlake’s future, what do you want the city to look like in 10, 20 and 30 years?


My view for Clearlake’s’ future is to be seen as a clean and spirited city. My hope is that around Austin Park would become the center of our community with small retail stores, coffee house, pizza place, a variety of different businesses. That the old Austin Resort and the center by City Hall would all be incorporated into this. That our park has more color with flowers and plants. That we have a pathway from behind City Hall down to Burns Valley Shopping Center along the river, wide enough for bicycles and walkers. That Lakeshore Drive Vision becomes reality and that people start taking pride in this community.


Council, city staff and police cannot alone make this happen. We are here to serve you but we cannot create an environment that people want to come to play and live in, that is up to the residents of Clearlake. They must clean up their properties by fixing broken down buildings or demolishing them. Paint and plant flowers, color brings beautiful and with beauty brings happiness and after all isn’t that what we are all after.


A place we can work and have pride in our community. That is my vision for the future of Clearlake. A place I can be proud to say, “This is my town!”


{mos_sb_discuss:3}

LCNews

Award winning journalism on the shores of Clear Lake. 

 

Search