- Elizabeth Larson
Council gets help solving fee waiver dilemma
Georgina Lehne, executive director of the Lake County Community Action Agency, asked the council to completely waive fees for use of the city's senior center, which the agency wants to use as the site of a fundraiser.
As Lake County News reported Thursday, Lehne said Lake County Community Action Agency needs to raise about $16,000 to make up for the shortfall suffered by last month's Blue Heron Rally.
Lehne plans to have a fundraiser to support the city's youth center and to make up for some of those losses. The senior center has the kitchen, barbecue and refrigeration facilities that are required, she said.
The nonprofit fee for using the senior center is $225 for four hours, half of the usual $450 fee, said Mayor Judy Thein. Each additional hour over the four hours would be $65 or half of that for the nonprofit fee.
City Administrator Dale Neiman said he believed this was a political decision so he offered the council no suggested action.
Community members Alice Reece and Aqeela El-Amin Bakheit, and youth center program director Joan Moore asked the city to honor Lehne's request and waive the fees.
But the majority of council members said the matter was more complicated than simply waiving the costs.
Councilman Chuck Leonard said the council had made a policy that all nonprofit groups renting the facility would receive a 50-percent discount, with no exceptions, until the city comes up with a more precise policy.
Leonard said he supports the youth center and regularly chaperones the twice-monthly dances with his wife, but he was concerned about being consistent.
Councilman Curt Giambruno agreed, saying they had turned down the Girl Scouts for a waiver which had given rise to the 50-percent fee reduction in order to make everything fair. "It's a tough one."
Councilmember Joyce Overton, who helped organize the Blue Heron Rally and has worked hard to support the youth center, paused to check if it was appropriate for her to discuss the matter before she offered her comments.
"I knew this was going to be a tough decision for everybody," she said.
Responding to her colleagues' reluctance to break with consistency, she said, "You also have to look at circumstances, and we all know the circumstances."
That statement referred to the allegations by organizers and motorcycle riders that the police presence at the event had been too large and caused riders to leave or stay away altogether.
Leonard said he knew what happened, and didn't think they should get into it, because it wasn't the City Council's fault.
Thein said they made a decision to be consistent. She pointed out that the City Council gave $2,000 to the Blue Heron Rally, they rent the youth center building to Lake County Community Action Agency for $1 a year and Thein herself is working on campaign to stop underage drinking.
"To say that we don't support our youth, that's without merit," said Thein.
At that point, an upset Overton gathered up her things and walked out of the meeting.
Former Councilmember Jo Bennett, sitting in the audience, asked to speak, which Thein allowed.
"This is really a serious issue, because you're damned if you do and you're damned if you don't," said Bennett.
Bennett suggested that the city should add a hardship provision to its facility rental policy in order to address situations like this one.
The center is very important, said Bennett, because it's a place where kids can go and be safe. She suggested that if Lake County Community Action Agency had the money, they wouldn't ask the city for the exclusion.
Giambruno said he liked the idea of adding a one-time hardship provision to a new rental policy.
Neiman said he and his wife were offering to donate $250 to the group to help them out.
Giambruno suggested that Neiman's donation could go toward the fee and the city could absorb the remainder.
Bennett offered to donate another $50, as did Councilman Roy Simons. Leonard's wife, Judy, pledged another $30.
Police Chief Allan McClain said he would match Neiman's $250 donation to the youth center.
The gestures of generosity all around drew applause from the audience.
The city could then cover the utilities, said Giambruno, although McClain said he would pay for those as well.
Thein said Bennett's suggestion of adding a hardship waiver was an excellent one, and asked Neiman to add it to the current guidelines.
The donations made it possible for the city to be consistent without Lake County Community Action Agency having to pay any fees out of pocket. Leonard moved to charge the reduced 50-percent fee, which the council adopted 4-0.
"Who's going to collect the money?" Simons asked after the vote.
Lehne said she would. Both McClain and Simon went to her in the audience afterward to make their donations.
The council also unanimously approved Lehne's request to make donation-funded improvements to the youth center, including painting and replacement of the floor and ceiling.
All labor will be donated by a group of 60 women with a PSI Seminar leadership group, Lehne said, with there being no cost to the city.
As Lehne left the meeting that night, she was followed out by audience members going to make additional donations.
Those wanting to make donations to Lake County Community Action Agency for the youth center, buy Harley-Davidson motorcycle raffle tickets (cost is $50), or purchase Blue Heron Rally T-shirts and pins, call Lehne at 995-2925 or Joan Moore at the youth center at 994-7281.
E-mail Elizabeth Larson at
{mos_sb_discuss:3}