CLEARLAKE – The Clearlake City Council heard an hour's worth of disappointment, anger and frustration from community members Thursday night over a Saturday motorcycle rally that organizers say failed due to an overzealous police presence.
A nearly filled council audience – more than 50 people attended the meeting – many of them motorcyclists were there to complain about the Blue Heron Rally, an event created to raise money for Lake County Community Action Agency.
As Lake County News first reported on Tuesday, the event had a large law enforcement presence, which Lake County Community Action Agency Executive Director Georgina Lehne and motorcyclists have said caused the low turnout.
Before opening up the meeting to public comment, Mayor Judy Thein asked City Administrator Dale Neiman to address the public.
Neiman said he realized not long after arriving at the city earlier this year that it needed new rules and procedures for dealing with special events.
He said the city must create a special event permitting process, with one point person in order to ensure all appropriate agencies are notified. A new process should include a special event application, he said.
Referring to Saturday's poker run, Neiman said one way it could have been handled better was coordinating traffic control at intersections as the motorcycle pack moved through the city.
"We didn't think about it because we didn't have these procedures in place," he said.
Neiman said they were asked for traffic control on the day of the event, but stopping traffic on the highway required that the California Highway Patrol and Caltrans be involved.
A new application process would help organizers know what information to provide, said Neiman.
As for the police presence, Neiman explained it by saying, "We operated under the assumption that as many as 10,000 people may attend the event." Agencies responded with a number of officers to cover that amount of people, he said.
Neiman said that, to his knowledge, only one Clearlake Police car was outside of city jurisdiction for the run, and that was because it was following two bikers wearing gang colors.
Neiman said the city wants to know about specific problems people had with city employees so they can investigate it.
"It's important to recognize tonight that the council can't make any decision related to any comments," he said, explaining that was because the topic wasn't on the agenda, which requires a formal request from an individual or group.
The council listened as more than a dozen people went to the podium to state their concerns. Also present for the meeting was Clearlake Police Chief Allan McClain, who listened but offered no responses or comments.
Joan Moore, director of the city's youth center, credited Councilwoman Joyce Overton – who also is Moore's sister – with her work on the rally and efforts to develop a youth center.
Moore said the event was a huge disappointment, which comes at a time when the youth center has signed up 65 youth for its programs, 64 of which are very low income and can't pay the program fees.
She said they're still raising money to help the young people, including selling leftover Blue Heron Rally T-shirts for $10 each.
Roy Sivertson, a Clearlake resident who spent 20 years in the Marines, said he sees gangs around Clearlake all the time, but they're not on motorcycles.
He said riders at the rally were treated like criminals by an oversized police force. Meanwhile, he said last November his home was burglarized and police told him they didn't have the money to process the fingerprints.
"How come you had the money to do what you did Saturday yet you don't have the money to process fingerprints?" he asked.
John Rice, who works at the Clearlake Safeway as a butcher and has ridden his Harley-Davidson motorcycle in hundreds of rally events, said four hears ago the Hells Angels held a run in Lake County and CHP were out in force to help control traffic.
"Nobody helped us Saturday. They harassed us. They got in the middle of the pack to break us up," Rice said.
When he tried to talk to McClain at the event, Rice said McClain rolled up his car window and wouldn't talk with them.
The community's children are the ones who really will suffer, said Rice. "There needs to be an explanation."
Marty Comito worked on organizing the event. She said that the Iron Pigs, who originally had been the event hosts, pulled out when they heard The Fryed Brothers were coming, accusing the band of an affiliation with the Hells Angels – an accusation band supporters and the band themselves have vehemently denied.
She blamed Clearlake Police Officer Tim Celli, an Iron Pigs member, for the club's decision to pull out of the event. She questioned the accusations against The Fryed Brothers, and reported that the Iron Pigs took part in a Hells Angels-sponsored run in Reno last year.
"The police department may have made a public relations blunder too big to cover up," Comito said.
Dante DeAmicis, who came to the meeting sporting his leather jacket, gave some of the evening's most colorful commentary on the rally's failure, stating that the city spent a lot of money to destroy a good cause.
He called Saturday's events and "ugly display of hysteria based on movie stereotypes."
DeAmicis said most bikers are middle class folks who have "honest money" in their pockets.
The fallout, he said, is that people will spread the word for hundreds of miles that
Clearlake is run by and for hicks, "blue-nosers" and paranoids.
Vic McManus, one of the riders who led Saturday's pack rider, said people came from all over to support the community's kids, only to run a law enforcement gauntlet and receive poor treatment.
He said when he tried to talk to McClain and shake his hand Saturday, McClain snatched his hand away. "I was disgusted, he should be, too," said McManus.
Responding to Neiman's comments about lack of communication between agencies, McManus said there must have been communication for there to be so much police presence at the rally.
He, too, referred to the CHP breaking up the bike pack which, which he said couldn't have been unintentional, as was the claim.
"The motorcycles I was with aren't coming back," he said.
Lehne spoke to the council, explaining her agency's many services to the community, including a food pantry which recently was hit with so much demand that they had to shut the doors in order to have time to restock it.
Lehne said rally participants and vendors from out of town have told her they will not come back to the county, a fact which is hurt the county's and the city's reputation. She estimated her agency lost $16,183 on the rally.
County Supervisor Jeff Smith said the county has many large events, some – such as BoardStock – with an even greater police presence. Yet those events succeed, he said.
"You just can't blame it on law enforcement," he said.
Bill MacDougall, principal of Carle Continuation High School and senior principal of Konocti Unified School District, said he wasn't there to point fingers.
"What happened was a shame," he said. "Who is to blame? I don't know."
A lot of people worked hard on the rally, said MacDougall. "As a community, we lost."
The community is moving in the right direction in helping the community's children, said MacDougall, who pointed to a huge homeless problem among children in the school system.
He attributed the rally's failure to a lack of communication, and urged the community to put it aside, learn from it and work together. "I know that we can do a lot better than we did."
Dr. Richard Savarese, a retired child psychologist, said he attended the event but didn't stay long because he was uncomfortable with the atmosphere created by the police presence.
He said the anger exhibited during the night's public comments is a secondary feeling, that the primary emotion is hurt.
The rally's failure, he said, has hurt people. "Hurting people is not the way for this place to move forward."
He said he thought there was a hidden agenda in the way the event was handled. "This is a dysfunctional system right now."
At the end of the meeting, during the councilmembers' communications, Overton offered her only comments about the rally she helped to organize.
"I'm really sorry how things turned out on that but we need to move on," she said.
Moving forward, Overton added that she wanted to try to turn a negative into a positive.
Lehne didn't present the city with a bill for the money the rally lost – she told Lake County News earlier this week that she was considering doing just that – but it's expected that the rally's outcome will be formally agendized for discussion by the council during its Sept. 13 meeting.
E-mail Elizabeth Larson at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..
{mos_sb_discuss:3}