
LAKE COUNTY, Calif. – Let’s get this straight.
Reserve Lake County Sheriff’s deputies Bill Burnett and Roth Shilts did not quit or retire even though between them they had 56 years of law enforcement in Lake County and 69 years overall.
Apparently, for reasons known only to Francisco Rivero – the one-term sheriff defeated in the primary by Brian Martin last June – the services of Burnett, 62, and Shilts, 68, were determined to no longer be needed.
Never mind that often those services put them in harm’s way.
“Absolutely,” said Martin, who was sworn in as Lake County's new sheriff in January. “We put them out in a patrol car just like a (full-time) deputy. And they arrested bad guys. A lot of the functions they performed while they were in uniform with a badge and with a gun. They were on patrol.
“They backed up our deputies on the street,” Martin added. “Their uniforms provided an opportunity for full-time guys to be safer. They functioned as full-time deputy sheriffs.”
Burnett found the action of Rivero in his case “completely ludicrous.”
“We were two guys who were perfectly capable volunteers and we’re told ‘We don’t want your services.’ Why would you say that to someone who is volunteering their services?” he asked.
The issue became all the stranger when in the spring of 2011 the two seasoned lawmen – each with an admirable personnel record – received a phone call from a captain in Rivero’s employ that basically said they were fired.
“The captain told me that he had been asked to collect my gear,” said Shilts.
“'What does that mean?’ I said. ‘Does it mean I’m fired?’He hesitated a bit and then said, ‘It appears so.’ I said, ‘For what?’ He said, ‘That’s all I can tell you,'” Shilts recalled.
“Then we started raising a fuss about what was going on,” he added.
That’s what sheriff’s Sgt. Don McPherson wanted to know, too, when he returned to Lake County after serving with the U.S. Army.
“I was in the Middle East when it happened,” said McPherson. “When I came back and was told they’re gone, fired, I said, 'Holy crap!' It was the dumbest thing I’d ever seen anybody do.”
“It was an absolute waste of two wonderful resources when we were short-staffed and under-manned. They were in the same uniform, carrying a gun and everything and driving a patrol car,” McPherson said.

“We didn’t assign them a beat or ask them to go out and handle burglaries, answer emergency domestic violence calls, stuff like that. They were out to support sworn deputies, do prisoner transport and security checks,” McPherson explained.
The least Rivero’s regime could have done was issue retirement badge to the two retiring deputies. But it didn’t, leaving that show of appreciation to Martin at a department-wide meeting in January.
The Lake County Deputy Sheriff's Association gave each of the men a plaque, as did the District Attorney’s Office.
“These guys have been around for quite some time. I was in middle school when they became officers. All we can do is give them our thanks, retire their badges and say goodbye in a way that is symbolic of their years of service,” said Martin.
“It would be nice if they were entitled to retirement pay,” the sheriff added.
“They got paid 60 minutes an hour,” quipped McPherson.
Both have experienced the dangerous side of law enforcement.
“I’ve had broken toes, sprained ankles and bruises,” said Shilts, who went into law enforcement after being mustered out of the Army with a 100-percent disability.
While serving in law enforcement in Antioch, Burnett was fired upon by a man with a rifle who has never been apprehended.
He has a son whose injuries forced him out of deputy work and another son who is a deputy in Butte County of 22 years' standing.
Burnett’s wife, Debbie, was a familiar face in the sheriff’s office until Rivero also eliminated her office assistant job.
The worst Shilts has seen, he said, is molestation that resulted in the death of infants.
“The worst for me is seeing kids being abused and involved in vehicle accidents because their parents were irresponsible enough to put them in that spot,” said Burnett.
Ultimately the two veterans and their function will fade into history – like dinosaurs, the last of a species, because of more stringent qualifications for reserve officers.
Both leave with regrets, Shilts because he wanted the distinction of a 30th year.
But short of another round at a police academy they cannot qualify. And both say they’ve had enough of academies.
Martin lauded the quality and spirit of volunteer deputies.
“It’s very demanding,” he said. Their hours are very rough and for somebody to do it for free is a difficult thing to ask. People of that caliber are few and far between.”
Email John Lindblom at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. .
