- Rich Mellott
SPORTS: Middletown sweeps by Upper Lake, 28-8
MIDDLETOWN, Calif. – If there was any question about who Lake County’s best football was (and there seemed to be some opposing opinions floating around recently in both the clear skies over Middletown and the smoky haze that’s enveloped Upper Lake), the Middletown Mustangs gave the definitive answer in a rare Monday night performance.
Austin Benson rushed for 192 yards in 24 carries and scored all four touchdowns and Middletown’s defense, after some adjustments at halftime, shut down Upper Lake’s power running game as the Mustangs pulled away for 28-8 victory at Bill Foltmer Field.
The game, originally scheduled for Saturday afternoon at Upper Lake, was pushed back to Monday afternoon – still at Upper Lake – because of all the smoke in the air generated by the Scotts Valley fire west of Scotts Valley Road and east of Ukiah.
But when Monday morning came around, the air quality wasn’t any better, so it was decided that if the non-league game was to be played, it had to be played at Middletown on Monday night. Kick-off was at 5:30 p.m. and, not surprisingly, a smaller-than-usual crowd attended the game.
“Playing at home is always an advantage,” said Mustang coach Bill Foltmer, but that could only partially explain Upper Lake’s problems on both sides of the ball.
The Cougars, who ran over Kelseyville in its opener, 52-6, had just one impressive drive, marching 74 yards midway through the second quarter, with Travis Coleman running it in from the 4.
Coleman’s pass to Wes Thaxton on the PAT gave the Cougars an 8-7 lead.
And it looked like a good game was starting to unfold between the county’s top two teams.
But that was about it for Upper Lake, which not only couldn’t stop Benson and the Middletown offense, but couldn’t generate any offense of its own.
“Middletown wanted it more than we did,” said a disappointed Alex Stabiner, coach of the Cougars.
Benson played like he wanted to score a lot of touchdowns. On the Mustangs’ first possession of the game, it looked like he would score on what would have been a 15-yard run, but had the ball stripped from him inside the Cougars’ 5-yard line, with Ward Beecher recovering for Upper Lake.
“I thought it could be a break-out game for him,” Foltmer said of his 5-foot-10, 180-pound running back. “He’s come close to breaking a few runs, nearly broke a couple against Salesian (in the season-opening 7-3 loss).”
And breaking out is what Benson did. The big play for him on Monday is called “toss right,” where he takes a quick pitch from quarterback Ben Pike and tries to get outsides the Cougar defense.
His 14-yard sweep made it 7-0 early in the second quarter and his 20-yard sweep made it 14-8 with 2:30 left in the half (with Tyler Drew adding both PAT kicks).
Benson, in a career-best performance, scored on yet another “toss right” touchdown on a 10-yard sweep that pushed the lead to 20-8 with 10:30 left in the third quarter.
And he added a 1-yard run in the fourth quarter to close out the scoring.
The Mustangs made some adjustments on defense in the second half, basically involving the linebackers and defensive backs remembering to shift accordingly to the Cougars’ offensive formation.
“We weren’t making the adjustments,” Foltmer said, “and they put together a couple of early drives on us. It was something we practiced all week, but we didn’t execute.”
Upper Lake coach Alex Stabiner had a different explanation for his team’s poor showing. “We got our butts whipped,” he said.
Email Rich Mellott at